Comparison Guide For Apple Pencil vs Logitech Crayon

When it comes to styluses for iPads, two names stand out: the Apple Pencil and the Logitech Crayon. Both are excellent tools designed to enhance productivity, creativity, and note-taking capabilities, but which one should you choose?

This comprehensive guide will help you decide by comparing the two based on design, performance, ergonomics, charging, compatibility, price, replacement tips, and storage. Let’s dive into the ultimate battle of smart styluses.

Design: Sleek vs. Practical

The Apple Pencil, in all its iterations, boasts a sleek and refined design that closely resembles a traditional pencil. Its circular shape, tapered tip, and minimalistic approach make it a stylish addition to any Apple device. However, the first-generation Apple Pencil had a slight flaw – it tended to roll off desks. Apple countered this issue by slightly weighting it, but it wasn't a perfect solution. The Apple Pencil 2 and Apple Pencil Pro solved this by introducing a flat edge that prevents rolling and enables magnetic charging.

On the other hand, the Logitech Crayon takes a more practical approach. Designed with students and classrooms in mind, the Crayon has a chunkier, rectangular design that eliminates rolling. Additionally, it features a built-in plastic cover for its charging port, making it more durable and child-friendly. Available in bright orange or a more subdued gray, the Logitech Crayon is built for resilience and practicality.

Winner: Apple Pencil 2, Apple Pencil Pro, Logitech Crayon (depends on user preference)

Performance: The Dealbreaker – Pressure Sensitivity

The primary difference in performance between the Apple Pencil and the Logitech Crayon is pressure sensitivity. The Apple Pencil (all models) offers pressure sensitivity, which is crucial for artists and illustrators who require fine-grained control over their strokes. The Apple Pencil Pro even goes a step further with features like barrel roll for tool orientation adjustment, squeeze controls, and haptic feedback.

The Logitech Crayon, however, lacks pressure sensitivity. While it does include tilt detection for shading and tool control, it simply cannot match the Apple Pencil’s precision for serious artwork. If you’re an artist or need to apply delicate effects in photo editing, the Apple Pencil is the clear winner. However, for basic note-taking, annotation, or general use, the Crayon performs well without pressure sensitivity.

Winner: Apple Pencil Pro, Apple Pencil (for artists); Logitech Crayon (for casual users)

Ergonomics: Comfort and Grip

The Apple Pencil mimics the size and shape of a real pencil, which makes it comfortable to use for extended periods. The Apple Pencil 1 had a glossy exterior that could become slippery, but Apple improved this with a matte finish on later models. The Logitech Crayon, being chunkier, offers a more secure grip, making it ideal for kids and users who prefer a larger stylus.

While both styluses are comfortable, the Apple Pencil’s lightweight and streamlined design gives it an edge for fine, precise work. The Crayon’s larger grip can be beneficial for users with larger hands or those who prefer a more robust feel.

Winner: Apple Pencil 2, Apple Pencil Pro (for artists and fine work); Logitech Crayon (for grip and durability)

Charging: Convenience and Battery Life

Charging methods vary significantly between these styluses. The Apple Pencil 1 had an awkward charging mechanism involving a Lightning connector hidden under a removable cap. This was later improved with the Apple Pencil 2 and Apple Pencil Pro, which introduced seamless wireless charging via magnetic attachment.

The Logitech Crayon uses a more traditional charging port. The first-generation Crayon used a Lightning cable, while the latest version features USB-C charging. Though not as seamless as wireless charging, the Crayon does have a power button, ensuring no battery waste when not in use. Additionally, it automatically shuts off after 30 minutes of inactivity to preserve battery life.

The Apple Pencil offers around 12 hours of battery life, while the Logitech Crayon lasts approximately 7.5 hours. However, the Crayon provides an LED battery indicator, while the Apple Pencil requires users to check the battery widget on their iPad.

Winner: Apple Pencil 2, Apple Pencil Pro (for wireless charging convenience); Logitech Crayon (for battery conservation)

Compatibility: Which iPads Do They Work With?

The Logitech Crayon is compatible with every iPad currently available, making it a universal option for Apple users. The Apple Pencil, however, requires careful selection based on your iPad model:

• Apple Pencil 1: Works with older iPads featuring a Lightning port.
• Apple Pencil 2: Compatible with newer iPads that support magnetic charging.
• Apple Pencil Pro: Designed for the latest iPads with advanced features.

Due to its universal compatibility, the Logitech Crayon is the more versatile option for users who own multiple iPads or need a stylus that works across generations.

Winner: Logitech Crayon

Price: Affordability vs. Features

Price is a significant factor in choosing between these two styluses:

• Apple Pencil 1: $89
• Apple Pencil 2: $129
• Apple Pencil Pro: $199
• Logitech Crayon: $69.95

For casual users, the Logitech Crayon offers excellent value, providing all essential features at nearly half the price of an Apple Pencil 2. However, for artists and professionals who require pressure sensitivity and additional features, the Apple Pencil justifies its higher price tag.

Winner: Logitech Crayon (for budget-conscious buyers); Apple Pencil (for professionals)

Replacement Tips: Availability and Longevity

Both the Apple Pencil and Logitech Crayon have replaceable tips, but there are differences in availability. The Apple Pencil comes with an extra tip, while the Crayon does not. Logitech sells Crayon replacement tips in packs of three for $14.99, but availability outside the U.S. is limited. Fortunately, Apple’s replacement tips work with the Crayon, though it’s not an ideal solution.

Apple’s replacement tips last a long time, often up to two years, depending on usage. However, using a screen protector may reduce their lifespan.

Winner: Apple Pencil (all models)

Storage: Keeping Your Stylus Secure

The Apple Pencil 2 and Apple Pencil Pro have an advantage in storage thanks to their magnetic attachment, which not only secures them to the iPad but also charges them. The Logitech Crayon lacks an official storage method, meaning users need to store it separately or rely on third-party cases.

If you frequently misplace small items, the Apple Pencil’s built-in storage solution is a game-changer.

Winner: Apple Pencil 2, Apple Pencil Pro

Which Should You Choose?

• For serious artists and professionals: The Apple Pencil (especially the Apple Pencil Pro) is the clear winner due to its pressure sensitivity, seamless wireless charging, and premium features.
• For students, note-takers, and casual users: The Logitech Crayon is a fantastic choice, offering solid performance, great durability, universal compatibility, and a lower price tag.
• For those who value convenience and seamless integration: The Apple Pencil 2 and Apple Pencil Pro’s magnetic charging and storage give them an edge over the Crayon.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your needs. If you’re an artist, the Apple Pencil is worth the investment. If you need a reliable, budget-friendly stylus for everyday use, the Logitech Crayon is a smart pick. Whichever you choose, both styluses will enhance your iPad experience significantly.